Ideas

When Civic Caring Breaks Down

Political polarization isn't just an ideological problem. It's a caring problem. When we stop being able to care about people we disagree with, democracy stops working.

When Civic Caring Breaks Down

There's a question I keep returning to when I look at the state of civic life in America.

It's not: why do people disagree so much? Disagreement is healthy. It's the engine of democratic deliberation. The question is: why has disagreement become so total? Why does it so often feel like the person on the other side isn't just wrong, but alien — not someone you could ever understand, let alone care about?

That shift — from disagreement to dehumanization — is a caring problem.

What Civic Caring Requires

Democratic society depends on a particular kind of caring that we rarely name explicitly. Call it civic caring: the capacity to hold some concern for the wellbeing of people you don't know, don't agree with, and may never meet.

It doesn't require liking everyone. It doesn't require agreeing. It requires something more minimal and more fundamental: the recognition that other people's lives matter, that their concerns are real, that they are not simply obstacles or enemies.

Civic caring is what makes it possible to lose an election and accept the result. To pay taxes that fund services you'll never use. To support institutions that sometimes rule against your interests. To extend good faith to a stranger.

When civic caring erodes, all of those things become harder. And they are becoming harder.

The Mechanics of Erosion

Civic caring doesn't collapse all at once. It erodes through a series of small steps, most of which feel reasonable in the moment.

It starts with sorting — the gradual separation of people into communities where everyone thinks roughly the same way. Sorting reduces exposure to difference, which reduces the practice of caring across difference, which makes difference feel more threatening.

Then comes the media environment, which has learned that outrage is more engaging than understanding. Every algorithm that surfaces the most enraging version of the other side is, in a small way, training us to see them as less than fully human.

Then comes the language. When political opponents become enemies. When disagreement becomes betrayal. When the other side isn't just wrong but evil.

Each step makes the next one easier. And at the end of the road is a civic life where caring only extends to people who are already like you — which is not civic caring at all. It's tribalism.

Why This Is a Caring Problem, Not Just a Political One

I want to be careful here. I'm not making a both-sides argument. Some positions are wrong. Some policies cause real harm. Caring about civic life doesn't mean treating all views as equally valid.

What it does mean is that the capacity to care — to stay curious about why someone believes what they believe, to hold their humanity even when you oppose their politics — is not a political position. It's a precondition for politics to function at all.

When we lose that capacity, we don't just get worse politics. We get a society that is less able to solve collective problems, less able to repair after conflict, less able to hold together under pressure.

The research on this is sobering. Societies with high levels of social trust — the sense that strangers are basically decent and that institutions are basically fair — are more economically productive, healthier, and more resilient. Social trust is, in part, a measure of how far civic caring extends.

We are spending down that trust at an alarming rate.

What Rebuilding Looks Like

I don't have a simple answer to this. Anyone who does is selling something.

But I do think the starting point is recognizing that civic caring is a practice, not a feeling. You don't have to feel warmly toward people you disagree with. You have to be willing to extend them the basic recognition that their concerns are real and their lives matter.

That practice is harder than it sounds, especially when the other side doesn't seem to be extending the same recognition to you. But it's not impossible. And it's not optional — not if we want to live in a society that functions.

We the People... Are Bad at This is, in part, a book about this problem. About what happens when civic caring breaks down, and what it might take to rebuild it. Not through optimism, but through honest reckoning with what we've lost and what it would cost to get it back.

---

Robert Bates is the author of [Why We Can't Stop Caring](/books/why-we-cant-stop-caring) and [We the People... Are Bad at This](/books/why-we-cant-stop-caring), a companion volume on civic life and democratic caring.